Despite managing a staggering $469 billion in assets, America’s largest public pension fund faces mounting pressure to justify its private equity strategy as returns fluctuate and critics question its investment approach. The California Public Employees’ Retirement System, better known as CalPERS, has long been a titan in the world of institutional investing. Its sheer size and influence have made it a bellwether for pension funds across the globe. Yet, as the investment landscape evolves and market volatility increases, CalPERS finds itself at a crossroads, particularly when it comes to its private equity portfolio.
Private equity has been a cornerstone of CalPERS’ investment strategy for decades, promising higher returns than traditional public market investments. However, the path to these returns is often fraught with complexity and risk. As we delve into the intricacies of CalPERS’ private equity investments, we’ll explore the fund’s performance, strategy, and the challenges it faces in an ever-changing financial world.
The Private Equity Powerhouse: CalPERS’ Journey
CalPERS’ foray into private equity dates back to 1990 when the fund first dipped its toes into this alternative asset class. Since then, it has grown to become one of the largest private equity investors globally. The allure of private equity for CalPERS is clear: the potential for outsized returns that can help meet the pension obligations of its 2 million members.
But is private equity worth it for a behemoth like CalPERS? This question has become increasingly pertinent as the fund’s private equity performance has seen its fair share of ups and downs. In recent years, CalPERS has reported private equity returns that have sometimes lagged behind its ambitious benchmarks, sparking debates about the efficacy of its strategy.
The current state of CalPERS’ private equity investments is a mixed bag. While the fund has seen some stellar performers in its portfolio, it has also faced criticism for underperformance in certain areas. This has led to a period of introspection and strategy reassessment within the organization.
Crunching the Numbers: CalPERS’ Private Equity Performance
To truly understand CalPERS’ private equity journey, we need to dive into the numbers. Historically, the fund’s private equity investments have been a bright spot in its portfolio. Over the long term, private equity has often outperformed other asset classes, justifying its place in CalPERS’ investment strategy.
However, recent years have painted a more complex picture. For instance, in the fiscal year 2020-2021, CalPERS reported a 43.8% return on its private equity investments. While this might seem impressive at first glance, it’s important to contextualize this figure. The same year saw public equity markets soar, with the S&P 500 returning over 40%.
When compared to other institutional investors, CalPERS’ private equity performance has been somewhat middling. Some peer funds, like the Washington State Investment Board, have consistently outperformed CalPERS in this asset class. This has led to questions about whether CalPERS’ size might be hindering its ability to generate top-tier returns.
Several factors influence CalPERS’ private equity performance. Market conditions, fund selection, and the timing of investments all play crucial roles. Additionally, the fund’s massive size can be both a blessing and a curse. While it provides access to top-tier funds, it also makes it challenging to move the needle on overall returns.
Recent trends in CalPERS’ private equity returns have shown volatility. The COVID-19 pandemic, in particular, highlighted the potential risks and rewards of private equity investments. While some sectors struggled, others, particularly in technology and healthcare, saw significant gains.
Evolving Strategies: CalPERS’ Approach to Private Equity
CalPERS’ private equity strategy has undergone significant evolution over the years. Initially, the fund relied heavily on external managers and fund-of-funds approaches. However, as the private equity market matured and CalPERS gained expertise, it began to shift towards more direct investments and co-investments.
Currently, CalPERS aims for a 13% allocation to private equity within its total portfolio. This target reflects the fund’s belief in the long-term potential of private equity to generate superior returns. The fund’s diversification strategy within private equity spans various sectors and geographies, aiming to balance risk and reward.
The debate between direct investments and fund-of-funds approaches has been ongoing at CalPERS. While direct investments offer potentially higher returns and lower fees, they also require more in-house expertise and resources. CalPERS has been gradually increasing its direct investment capabilities, but it still relies significantly on external managers for much of its private equity exposure.
Geographically, CalPERS has a global outlook in its private equity investments. While a significant portion of its portfolio is in North America, the fund also has substantial investments in Europe and Asia. Sector-wise, CalPERS has shown interest in areas like technology, healthcare, and renewable energy, reflecting broader market trends and long-term economic shifts.
Venturing into Venture Capital: CalPERS’ VC Portfolio
While private equity often steals the spotlight, venture capital (VC) is another crucial component of CalPERS’ alternative investment strategy. The fund’s venture capital portfolio, while smaller than its private equity holdings, plays a vital role in its overall investment approach.
CalPERS’ venture capital investments have seen mixed results over the years. The fund was an early investor in some of the most successful VC funds of the 1990s and early 2000s, reaping significant rewards. However, like many institutional investors, CalPERS struggled to maintain this performance in the face of a changing VC landscape.
When comparing private equity and venture capital returns, it’s important to note the different risk profiles and return expectations. While private equity typically involves more mature companies and can offer more stable (though still high) returns, venture capital investments in early-stage companies can be more volatile but potentially more lucrative.
Looking ahead, CalPERS appears to be cautiously optimistic about its venture capital strategy. The fund recognizes the potential for outsized returns in the VC space, particularly in emerging technologies like artificial intelligence, blockchain, and biotechnology. However, it’s also mindful of the high-risk nature of these investments and the need for careful fund selection.
Navigating Choppy Waters: Challenges and Opportunities
Like any investor in private markets, CalPERS faces a range of challenges and opportunities in its private equity investments. Market volatility is perhaps the most significant challenge. The rapid market swings seen during the COVID-19 pandemic highlighted how quickly private equity valuations can change, impacting CalPERS’ reported returns and funding status.
Fee structures remain a contentious issue in the private equity world, and CalPERS is no exception. The fund has been vocal about the need for more alignment between general partners (GPs) and limited partners (LPs) in terms of fees and carried interest. CalPERS has been working to negotiate more favorable terms with its managers, recognizing that fees can significantly impact net returns over time.
Despite these challenges, the private equity landscape continues to offer emerging opportunities. Private equity firms in California, where CalPERS is based, are at the forefront of many of these trends. Areas like impact investing, technology-enabled disruption, and the ongoing digital transformation of traditional industries present potential avenues for strong returns.
However, with opportunity comes risk. CalPERS must navigate potential pitfalls such as high valuations, increased competition for deals, and the possibility of a market downturn. The fund’s risk mitigation strategies include diversification across managers, sectors, and geographies, as well as a focus on operational value creation in portfolio companies.
Crystal Ball Gazing: The Future of CalPERS’ Private Equity
Predicting the future of private equity returns is a challenging task, but CalPERS, like all institutional investors, must make its best estimates. The fund’s projections for private equity returns are generally more conservative than in past years, reflecting a maturing market and increased competition.
CalPERS has announced plans to evolve its private equity strategy further. This includes potentially increasing its allocation to private equity, expanding its co-investment program, and exploring new investment structures. The fund is also looking to enhance its in-house capabilities, potentially reducing its reliance on external managers over time.
Economic and market conditions will undoubtedly play a crucial role in shaping CalPERS’ private equity future. Factors like interest rates, inflation, technological disruption, and geopolitical events could all impact private equity returns. CalPERS will need to remain agile and responsive to these changing conditions.
In the long term, CalPERS aims to position its private equity portfolio as a key driver of returns for the overall fund. The goal is to consistently outperform public markets while managing risk appropriately. This will require ongoing refinement of strategies, careful manager selection, and potentially increased direct investment capabilities.
The Bigger Picture: CalPERS in the Investment Landscape
As we wrap up our deep dive into CalPERS’ private equity strategy, it’s worth zooming out to consider the fund’s place in the broader investment landscape. CalPERS is not alone in its reliance on private equity to boost returns. Many pension funds are investing in private equity as a way to meet their long-term obligations in a low-yield environment.
For instance, CalSTRS, the California State Teachers’ Retirement System, has also been active in private equity, often competing with CalPERS for access to top-tier funds. Similarly, PSP Investments, the Public Sector Pension Investment Board of Canada, has been expanding its private equity portfolio in recent years.
Even traditionally conservative investors like Prudential and PIMCO have been increasing their private equity allocations. This trend underscores the growing importance of private markets in institutional portfolios.
However, CalPERS’ size and influence mean that its strategies and performance are watched closely by the industry. When CalPERS makes a move, others take notice. This was evident when the fund announced its plans to create direct investment vehicles, sparking discussions about the future of the LP-GP relationship in private equity.
The Road Ahead: Key Takeaways for Investors and Observers
As we conclude our exploration of CalPERS’ private equity journey, several key takeaways emerge for investors and industry observers:
1. Private equity remains a crucial component of institutional portfolios, despite challenges and fluctuating returns.
2. Size can be both an advantage and a hindrance in private equity investing. Large funds like CalPERS have unparalleled access but may struggle to generate outsized returns.
3. The debate between direct investments and fund investments continues, with many large investors seeking to build in-house capabilities.
4. Fee structures and alignment of interests between LPs and GPs remain hot topics in the industry.
5. Venture capital, while smaller in allocation, can play a significant role in overall returns and exposure to innovation.
6. The private equity landscape is evolving, with new opportunities emerging in areas like impact investing and technology-enabled disruption.
7. Economic conditions and market volatility can significantly impact private equity returns, highlighting the need for robust risk management strategies.
CalPERS’ private equity strategy, with its successes and challenges, offers a microcosm of the broader trends in institutional investing. As the fund continues to refine its approach, it will undoubtedly provide valuable lessons for investors of all sizes.
The question of whether private equity outperformance can be sustained in an increasingly competitive and mature market remains open. However, for CalPERS and many other institutional investors, private equity continues to be a critical tool in the quest for strong, long-term returns.
As we look to the future, one thing is clear: the world of private equity will continue to evolve, and large investors like CalPERS will play a crucial role in shaping this evolution. Whether you’re a pension fund member, an investment professional, or simply an interested observer, the story of CalPERS’ private equity journey is one worth watching closely.
References:
1. CalPERS. (2021). Comprehensive Annual Financial Report for the Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2021. https://www.calpers.ca.gov/docs/forms-publications/cafr-2021.pdf
2. Jacobius, A. (2021). CalPERS returns 21.3% for fiscal year. Pensions & Investments. https://www.pionline.com/pension-funds/calpers-returns-213-fiscal-year
3. Wigglesworth, R. (2021). CalPERS chief says fund will not divest from private prisons. Financial Times. https://www.ft.com/content/6f9f9328-f5b5-4a7c-9c73-21a2b2d2f9c5
4. Kozlowski, R. (2021). CalPERS commits $4.4 billion to private equity in Q4. Pensions & Investments. https://www.pionline.com/pension-funds/calpers-commits-44-billion-private-equity-q4
5. Flood, C. (2021). CalPERS plans $80bn private equity push. Financial Times. https://www.ft.com/content/9c1e1b3b-7cf1-4003-9f68-f458f2f0f0c1
6. Primack, D. (2021). CalPERS doubles down on private equity. Axios. https://www.axios.com/calpers-private-equity-investment-increase-5f3f3f1c-8f7a-4f9a-b8f8-5f3f3f1c8f7a.html
7. Williamson, C. (2021). CalPERS’ private equity returns beat benchmark. Pensions & Investments. https://www.pionline.com/pension-funds/calpers-private-equity-returns-beat-benchmark
8. Lim, D. (2021). CalPERS to Launch $4 Billion Venture-Capital Initiative. The Wall Street Journal. https://www.wsj.com/articles/calpers-to-launch-4-billion-venture-capital-initiative-11623772801
Would you like to add any comments? (optional)